On 19 March 1831, New York City witnessed its first-ever recorded bank robbery, marking the beginning of a criminal trend that would become more sophisticated over the years. The target was City Bank of New York, known today as Citibank, located at 52 Wall Street.
The bank and its significance
City Bank of New York was a growing financial institution in the early 19th century, playing a crucial role in the city’s expanding economy. Founded in 1812, it was still in its early years but had already become a trusted establishment for businesses and individuals alike.
Despite its importance, banking security at the time was relatively lax compared to modern standards. Vaults were rudimentary, alarm systems were non-existent, and the concept of surveillance cameras was nearly a century away. Banks primarily relied on locked doors, strongboxes, and trusted employees to protect their assets.
The robbery
On the night of 19 March 1831, thieves gained access to City Bank using duplicate keys, suggesting an inside job or meticulous planning. They managed to break into the vault and escape with a staggering $245,000 – a massive sum for the time, equivalent to several million dollars today.
Unlike the dramatic, gun-wielding bank robberies of the Wild West that would follow decades later, this was a silent, well-planned theft, executed without violence. The criminals took advantage of the limited security measures of the era, slipping away unnoticed.
The investigation and aftermath
The robbery shocked New York City and led to a major manhunt. Authorities worked swiftly to track down the culprits, and within a few days, suspicion fell on Edward Smith, a known criminal with a history of theft. Smith was arrested, tried, and convicted, receiving a sentence of five years of hard labour at Sing Sing prison.
Although much of the stolen money was never recovered, Smith’s conviction sent a strong message about the increasing necessity for better banking security. Following the robbery, financial institutions began implementing stricter security protocols, including stronger vaults and better hiring practices to prevent insider crimes.
Legacy of the heist
The 1831 City Bank robbery was a landmark event in American criminal history. It set a precedent for bank heists in the United States and led to the gradual evolution of bank security systems. As urban centres grew and banking became more centralised, financial institutions were forced to adopt more advanced protective measures, ultimately paving the way for the security systems we see today.
While Edward Smith may not have been the last to attempt robbing a bank, he was certainly one of the first to be caught, ensuring that his name remains tied to one of New York City’s most infamous early crimes.
Also read: ON THIS DAY: Remembering Venizelos (1936) and Elytis (1996)
