Young Spanish woman wins right to assisted dying
Noelia Castillo, a 25-year-old woman from Barcelona, has died by euthanasia after a lengthy legal struggle with her father over her right to end her life. Castillo, who became paraplegic following a 2022 suicide attempt, had been granted the right to assisted dying by the Catalan government in 2024, but her father’s legal challenges delayed the process.
She was raped on two occasions, once by her ex-boyfriend and the second time by three boys in 2022, describing this as a turning point in her life.
She jumped from the fifth-floor window of an apartment building in a cocaine-fuelled attempt to end her own life in October 2022 after previously overdosing on medication, according to legal rulings.
The fall left her paralysed from the waist down, and she was suffering severe, chronic and incapacitating pain with no possibility of improvement, her medical reports show.
European Court of Human Rights rules in her favour
The legal battle lasted 18 months, during which Castillo’s father, supported by the conservative group Christian Lawyers (Abogados Cristianos), argued she suffered from a personality disorder that affected her judgement. The case concluded when the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled in her favour, allowing her euthanasia to proceed.
Castillo speaks on personal struggles
Before her death, Castillo recounted a difficult childhood spent largely in care homes, as well as multiple sexual assaults. She emphasised her determination to die with dignity despite opposition from her family. “The happiness of a father or a mother or a sister shouldn’t precede the happiness of a daughter,” she said.
Impact on Spain’s euthanasia law
Spain’s euthanasia law, in effect since 2021, had never before gone to court. Government data shows 426 requests for assisted dying were granted in 2024. Abogados Cristianos stated that Castillo’s case “highlights the serious flaws” in Spain’s euthanasia legislation, bringing attention to legal and ethical debates surrounding assisted dying.
Assisted dying laws around the world
United States
Assisted dying, sometimes called assisted suicide, is legal in ten US states and Washington DC. Oregon was among the first to allow it in 1997, setting a model for other states.
Eligibility is limited to terminally ill, mentally competent adults expected to die within six months, with approval from two doctors. Since 1997, 4,274 patients have received prescriptions for lethal medication, with 2,847 deaths (67%). Most patients cite loss of autonomy as a key reason, followed by loss of dignity, control over bodily functions, concerns about burdening family, inadequate pain control, and financial implications.
The medication must be self-administered, a rule also proposed for England and Wales. Approximately one-third of patients prescribed the lethal dose do not proceed. Some rules in Oregon have been relaxed over time, such as residency requirements, and the number of assisted deaths has increased.
Canada
Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) began in 2016 for the terminally ill and was expanded in 2021 to include those experiencing “unbearable suffering” from irreversible conditions. Future expansions will cover mental illness. Critics argue these changes put vulnerable populations at risk. Currently, around 4% of Canadian deaths are medically assisted, compared to about 1% in Oregon.
Europe
Six European countries – Switzerland, the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Spain, and Austria – allow assisted dying, often extending it beyond terminal illnesses. Switzerland, the first country to legalise assisted suicide in 1942, allows foreigners to access assisted dying through organisations such as Dignitas. The Netherlands and Belgium permit euthanasia and assisted dying for patients, including minors, experiencing unbearable suffering. Spain and Austria recently legalised assisted dying for terminal illness and intolerable suffering, with Austria requiring self-administration and Spain allowing professional administration.
Similar legislation is being considered in Scotland, and the Isle of Man is expected to pass a bill permitting assisted dying for adults with less than 12 months to live, potentially taking effect in 2027. Jersey is also planning changes for terminally ill patients.
Australia and New Zealand
Voluntary assisted dying is now legal in most of Australia and in New Zealand. Patients must be terminally ill, expected to die within six months (or 12 months for neurodegenerative conditions in Australia), and can self-administer medication. In both countries, a doctor or nurse may also administer it, usually via intravenous injection.
Also read: Ukraine Saudi defence talks during Zelensky visit
For more videos and updates, check out our YouTube channel
