The issue of whether a navigation app like Google Maps can be held responsible for road accidents has arisen in India following a tragic incident in the state of Uttar Pradesh. Three people lost their lives when their car plunged off an unfinished bridge. Authorities believe the app led the passengers onto the wrong route, as there were no signs or barricades to warn about the condition of the bridge.
Local authorities have filed a complaint against four engineers from the local roadworks department and an unnamed representative of Google Maps, accusing them of negligent homicide. Google is cooperating with authorities to investigate the incident.
Google Maps horror :
— Surya Reddy (@jsuryareddy) November 24, 2024
Wrong #GPS location took the lives of 3 people in #Bareilly, #UttarPradesh#GoogleMaps directed a car to a half-finished bridge.
Due to dense #fog, the incomplete bridge was not visible and the car falls into the #RamgangaRiver, resulting in the death of… pic.twitter.com/uTCMKTz7xG
Google Maps horror :
— Surya Reddy (@jsuryareddy) November 24, 2024
Wrong #GPS location took the lives of 3 people in #Bareilly, #UttarPradesh#GoogleMaps directed a car to a half-finished bridge.
Due to dense #fog, the incomplete bridge was not visible and the car falls into the #RamgangaRiver, resulting in the death of… pic.twitter.com/uTCMKTz7xG
The tragedy has spotlighted the poor state of India’s road infrastructure and sparked a debate about the responsibility of navigation apps. Similar accidents have occurred in the past due to incorrect directions provided by Google Maps. The app relies on satellite data, user feedback, and alerts from authorities to update its maps. However, managing this data is challenging due to the enormous volume of information and the lack of efficient reporting systems in India.
Legally, such apps are protected under Indian law as “intermediary service providers.” However, if it is proven that they ignored timely and accurate updates, they may be held liable for negligence.
Also read: 12 dead and over 300,000 affected in Sri Lanka tropical storm
