Woman awarded €82,000 in compensation for permanent eye damage

Date:

An eye doctor has failed in a bid to add 16 new grounds to an appeal against a €82,347 damages award over the permanent eye damage suffered by a teenager, after the Court of Appeal ruled that his application had been filed after an excessive and unjustified delay.

In a unanimous decision issued on 18 November 2026, the Court rejected the request, finding that allowing the amendments would prejudice the woman’s rights and make it more difficult to hear the case within a reasonable time.

The doctor was also ordered to pay €2,000 in legal costs to the woman.

Eye infection led to permanent damage

The case dates back to 2006, when the woman was 17 and attending the third year of secondary school in Paphos.

She had suffered from short-sightedness since childhood and used contact lenses of a particular brand. In September 2006, she developed discomfort and an infection in her left eye.

After consulting ophthalmologists in Cyprus, she travelled to Athens, where she received treatment from the doctor involved in the case over an extended period.

When the treatment failed to produce the expected results, she travelled to London in March 2007. There, she was diagnosed with acanthamoeba keratitis, a serious eye infection.

The condition left her with permanent damage, including partial blindness in her left eye, sensitivity to light and scarring of the cornea.

Court awarded more than €82,000 in damages

In 2009, the woman filed a civil lawsuit against six defendants, seeking compensation for her injuries, expenses, losses, pain and suffering.

She alleged that the manufacturers and importers of the contact lenses, as well as the Republic of Cyprus in connection with their importation, bore responsibility. She also accused the ophthalmologist of failing to exercise the necessary skill and care in carrying out his medical duties.

On 28 April 2021, the Paphos District Court ruled in her favour against the ophthalmologist. It awarded her €70,000 in general damages, €7,000 for future expenses and €5,347.45 in special damages, plus interest and costs.

The claims against the other five defendants were dismissed.

The doctor filed an appeal on 9 June 2021, setting out 11 grounds challenging the first-instance judgment. The woman also filed her own appeal, which remains pending.

Doctor sought to add 16 new grounds

On 7 July 2026, after the doctor’s appeal had already been scheduled for a pre-trial hearing, he applied to add a paragraph to an existing ground of appeal and introduce 16 additional grounds.

His legal team argued that, following the first-instance judgment, he had wanted to review the decision with a lawyer in Greece. They also said that not all the court transcripts had been available to his lawyers when the original appeal was prepared.

According to the application, a recent review of the transcripts had revealed the need to introduce further grounds to present his case more fully.

The woman’s legal team opposed the request, arguing that it was abusive, out of time and insufficiently justified. They maintained that the doctor was attempting to restructure the appeal by introducing new, independent arguments that had either been known from the outset or could have been raised earlier.

Court cites five-year delay

In examining the application, the Court of Appeal referred to the Civil Procedure Rules introduced in 2023. Under the rules, amendments to a notice of appeal require the court’s permission, while the general principles governing amendments to pleadings apply by analogy.

The court said the central consideration was the overriding objective: ensuring that cases are dealt with fairly and at proportionate cost.

It identified procedural shortcomings in the application but placed particular emphasis on the delay.

The affidavit supporting the request did not specify when the doctor began reviewing the judgment with the lawyer in Greece, how long that process took, when the transcripts were requested or when the need to amend the appeal arose.

The court noted that approximately five years had passed before the application was submitted, without a specific and adequate explanation. It also highlighted that the request came after the appeal had already been scheduled for a pre-trial hearing, potentially causing a significant postponement.

The proposed amendments were also extensive. Eleven of the new grounds were connected to existing ones, while five had no direct connection to them. The court considered this an apparent attempt to rebuild the appeal on a new and broader basis.

Woman’s right to a timely hearing considered

The judges also took into account the length of time the woman had already been waiting for the case to conclude.

She had been awaiting the hearing of the doctor’s appeal and the final outcome of a legal dispute that began in 2009. Allowing the amendments would have required her to expand her legal preparation, incurring additional time and costs.

The court stressed that an award of legal costs would not adequately compensate her for this additional burden.

It therefore concluded that granting the application would run counter to the overriding objective of the Civil Procedure Rules and undermine the fair and proportionate administration of justice.

The Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed the doctor’s application to amend his grounds of appeal and ordered him to pay €2,000 in costs to the woman.


Also read: Dispute over money and services led to fatal stabbing of Vietnamese woman
For more videos and updates, check out our YouTube channel

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Voyager 1 reaches one light-day distance from Earth

NASA's Voyager 1 has become the first human-made object...

Limassol private hospital restricts access to external paediatricians

A private hospital in Limassol has sparked reactions after...

Nurses seek retirement at 60 instead of 65

Nurses in Cyprus are calling for the retirement age...

GESY covers medical treatment abroad, subject to conditions and limits

GESY beneficiaries can receive medical treatment in another European...